Guided By Birds: Avian data to guide Clayton Hill restoration
This post was written by Robin Eng, Ecological Project Manager for the Pittsburgh Parks Conservancy.
Forest restoration is a moving target. To measure the impacts and progress of restoration efforts practitioners must choose certain quantifiable elements of an ecosystem that can indicate habitat quality. For the restoration site in Frick Park known as Clayton Hill, we have been monitoring bird species during the summer breeding and fall migration seasons to interpret the habitat quality of the areas we are working to restore. Metrics about avian populations provide us with an honest evaluation of the function of our restoration sites because they are not something that we can directly control (as opposed to things like plant species diversity, or forest canopy cover which we actively change through native species plantings). Now, two years into our avian monitoring process our partners at the Western PA Conservancy (WPC) have compiled our first summary report about the bird species that rely on Clayton Hill for fall migration and summer breeding habitat.
To monitor the birds on Clayton Hill, we divided the whole restoration area into four monitoring units (Fig 1). We divided the site this way to control for topographic features such as aspect (north facing vs south facing), elevation (ridge top vs creek bottom), or slope (flat land vs steep hillside) that might inherently attract different bird communities. By monitoring these areas separately, we can also determine if specific units seem to be increasing or decreasing in avian habitat value. In turn, this helps us determine priorities for future restoration efforts.
While it may seem straightforward at first, any ecological monitoring is a time-consuming task. Good data is dependent on repeated sampling, and it can be challenging to acquire the human-capacity required to collect all the information we’d like. Fortunately, through the eBird app we can utilize the observations of volunteer citizen scientists to help monitor the Clayton Hill restoration area. eBird is a product of The Cornell Lab or Ornithology, and it provides a platform that birders everywhere can use to record their bird observations. Partners from the WPC and Carnegie Museum of Natural History’s (CMNH) Powdermill Nature Reserve established ‘eBird hotspots’ for each Clayton Hill restoration unit. By logging bird observation to these eBird hotspots, bird-watching park users are able to perform bird surveys on their own time in our specific monitoring units. These citizen scientists are imperative for the continued monitoring and successful progress of our ecological restoration work.
In 2020 and 2021, researchers and citizen scientists observed 116 species of birds utilizing the Clayton Hill restoration area during the breeding and fall migration seasons (Table 1, below). The Clayton North monitoring unit had the highest species richness (the highest number of unique species observed) in 3 of the 4 monitoring periods (Figure 1). We saw the lowest species richness in the “Nature Trail East” unit, but also had the fewest number of checklists completed in this area (Figure 2). Total bird abundance (the number of individual birds observed) varied across sites and seasons, however survey effort was also inconsistent across seasons, which likely added variance to these early data. For more details, you can view the full report here.
While these data are interesting on their own, the most useful data for evaluating restoration will come from our ability to identify trends over time. These first two years of data are only the baseline numbers that we can use for future comparisons. In the coming years our dataset will grow alongside our restoration plants, and as it does we hope to discover new insights about the changing quality of the Clayton Hill habitat. In the meantime, patience is a requirement. Meaningful restoration occurs on the timescale of years to decades, as it takes plants that long to become established and even longer for them to serve their full suite of ecosystem services. As the native species that we’ve added to Clayton Hill grow, we hope they will provide food and improve habitat for a wide range of bird species. But if we grow it, will they come? Although birds have been observed to show remarkable memory for quality habitat along their migration routes (Mettke-Hofmann and Gwinner. 2003), they first have to discover a site worth remembering. For this reason, it’s important that we’re always looking for opportunities to scale up our restoration efforts and improve connectivity between forest sites.
Already, partners who’ve been working on the Clayton Hill restoration project are using initial observations of avian habitat quality to inform our next management steps. An invasive annual grass called Japanese stiltgrass (Microstegium vimineum) has been steadily expanding through much of Clayton North and Clayton East, and an alarm has been raised that this grass is causing trouble for ground-dwelling migratory songbirds. Given this reality, we are focusing on the habitat needs of those species when designing future projects and workplans – for instance planting shrubs and perennials that will stand up (literally) against the crushing weight of a field of bolting stiltgrass (below).
At Clayton Hill, we are several years into our work facilitating regeneration of native forest habitat but we are still decades away from our goal of achieving a stable, productive, and biodiverse urban forest ecosystem. The presence and abundance of bird species that thrive in healthy native forest communities will keep us honest about our progress, while the tireless work and passion of our many partners keeps us all moving forward in the best ways that we know how. If you’re interested in learning more, we invite you to come out for our fall World Migratory Bird Day event at the Frick Environmental Center on October 8. We also welcome all birders to submit an eBird checklist using our Clayton Hill Hotspots!
This project would not be possible without the joint efforts of the Western Pennsylvania Conservancy, Carnegie Museum of Natural History, Allegheny GoatScape, the Allegheny County Bird Alliance, and the dozens of citizen scientists, volunteers, and donating organizations who’ve contributed to this project. The Clayton Hill Restoration work has been supported by funding from the National Fish and Wildlife Federation, the Pittsburgh Foundation, the PA Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, and donations from Pittsburgh’s park users.
Table 1 (below): Birds species observed on Clayton Hill from 2020-2021. Also reported are the conservation status and population trends of these species as determined by the International Union for Conservation of Nature, and indication of species that are designated of greatest conservation need by the PA State Wildlife Action Plan.
Species | Scientific Name | IUCN Conservation Status | IUCN Population Trend | PA SWAP Greatest need |
Acadian Flycatcher | Empidonax virescens | Least Concern | Stable | |
American Crow | Corvus brachyrhynchos | Least Concern | Increasing | |
American Goldfinch | Spinus tristis | Least Concern | Increasing | |
American Redstart | Setophaga ruticilla | Least Concern | Increasing | |
American Robin | Turdus migratorius | Least Concern | Stable | |
Baltimore Oriole | Icterus galbua | Least Concern | Stable | |
Barred Owl | Strix varia | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Bay-breasted Warbler | Setophaga castanea | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Black-and-white Warbler | Mniotilta varia | Least Concern | Stable | Yes |
Black-billed Cuckoo | Coccyzus erythropthalmus | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Blackburnian Warbler | Setophaga fusca | Least Concern | Increasing | Yes |
Black-capped Chickadee | Poecile atricapillus | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Blackpoll Warbler | Setophaga striata | Near Threatened | Decreasing | Yes |
Black-throated Blue Warbler | Setophaga caerulescens | Least Concern | Increasing | Yes |
Black-throated Green Warbler | Setophaga virens | Least Concern | Stable | Yes |
Blue Jay | Cyanocitta cristata | Least Concern | Stable | |
Blue-gray Gnatcatcher | Polioptila caerulea | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Blue-headed Vireo | Vireo solitarius | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Blue-winged Warbler | Vermivora cyanoptera | Least Concern | Decreasing | Yes |
Brown Creeper | Certhia americana | Least Concern | Increasing | Yes |
Brown-headed Cowbird | Molothrus ater | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Canada Goose | Branta Canadensis | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Canada Warbler | Cardellina canadensis | Least Concern | Decreasing | Yes |
Cape May Warbler | Setophaga tigrine | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Carolina Chickadee | Poecile carolinensis | Least Concern | Stable | |
Carolina Wren | Thryothorus ludovicianus | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Cedar Waxwing | Bombycilla cedrorum | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Cerulean Warbler | Setophaga cerulea | Near Threatened | Decreasing | Yes |
Chestnut-sided Warbler | Setophaga pensylvanica | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Chimney Swift | Chaetura pelagica | Vulnerable | Decreasing | Yes |
Chipping Sparrow | Spizella passerine | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Common Grackle | Quiscalus quiscula | Near Threatened | Decreasing | |
Common Nighthawk | Chordeiles minor | Least Concern | Decreasing | Yes |
Common Raven | Corvus corax | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Common Yellowthroat | Geothylpis trichas | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Connecticut Warbler | Oporornis agilis | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Cooper's Hawk | Accipiter cooperii | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Dark-eyed Junco | Junco hyemalis | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Double-crested Cormorant | Nannopterum auritus | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Downy Woodpecker | Dryobates pubescens | Least Concern | Stable | |
Eastern Bluebird | Silia sialis | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Eastern Phoebe | Sayornis phoebe | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Eastern Towhee | Pipilo erythrophthalmus | Least Concern | Decreasing | Yes |
Eastern Wood-Pewee | Contopus virens | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
European Starling | Sturnus vulgaris | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Field Sparrow | Spizella pusilla | Least Concern | Decreasing | Yes |
Fish Crow | Corvus ossifragus | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Golden-crowned Kinglet | Regulus satrapa | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Gray Catbird | Dumetella carolinensis | Least Concern | Stable | Yes |
Gray-cheeked Thrush | Catharus minimus | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Great Blue Heron | Ardea herodias | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Great Crested Flycatcher | Myiarchus crinitus | Least Concern | Stable | |
Great Horned Owl | Bubo virginianus | Least Concern | Stable | |
Hairy Woodpecker | Leuconotopicus villosus | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Hermit Thrush | Catharus guttatus | Least Concern | Stable | |
Hooded Warbler | Setophaga citrina | Least Concern | Increasing | Yes |
House Finch | Haemorhous mexicanus | Least Concern | Increasing | |
House Sparrow | Passer domesticus | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
House Wren | Troglodytes aedon | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Indigo Bunting | Passerina cyanea | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Kentucky Warbler | Geothlypis formosa | Least Concern | Decreasing | Yes |
Least Flycatcher | Empidonax minimus | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Lincoln's Sparrow | Melospiza lencolnii | Least Concern | Stable | |
Magnolia Warbler | Setophaga magnolia | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Mallard | Leuconotopicus villosus | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Marsh Wren | Cistothorus palustris | Least Concern | Increasing | Yes |
Merlin | Falco columbarius | Least Concern | Stable | |
Mourning Dove | Zenaida macroura | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Mourning Warbler | Geothlypis philadelphia | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Nashville Warbler | Leiothlypis ruficapilla | Least Concern | Stable | Yes |
Northern Cardinal | Cardinalis cardinalis | Least Concern | Stable | |
Northern Flicker | Colaptes auratus | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Northern Mockingbird | Mimus polyglottos | Least Concern | Stable | |
Northern Parula | Setophaga americana | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Olive-sided Flycatcher | Contopus cooperi | Near Threatened | Decreasing | Yes |
Orchard Oriole | Icterus spurius | Least Concern | Stable | |
Ovenbird | Seiurus aurocapilla | Least Concern | Stable | |
Palm Warbler | Setophaga palmarum | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Philadelphia Vireo | Vireo philadelphicus | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Pileated Woodpecker | Hylatomus pileatus | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Pine Warbler | Setophaga pinus | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Purple Finch | Haemorhous purpureus | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Red-bellied Woodpecker | Melanerpes carolinus | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Red-breasted Nuthatch | Sitta canadensis | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Red-eyed Vireo | Vireo olivaceus | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Red-shouldered Hawk | Buteo lineatus | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Red-tailed Hawk | Buteo jamaicensis | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Red-winged Blackbird | Agelaius phoeniceus | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Ring-billed Gull | Larus delawarensis | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Rock Pigeon | Columba livia | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Ruby-crowned Kinglet | Regulus calendula | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Ruby-throated Hummingbird | Archilochus colubris | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Scarlet Tanager | Piranga olivacea | Least Concern | Stable | Yes |
Sharp-shinned Hawk | Accipiter striatus | Least Concern | Increasing | Yes |
Song Sparrow | Melospiza melodia | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Swainson's Thrush | Catharus swainsoni | Least Concern | Stable | |
Tennessee Warbler | Leiothlypis peregrina | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Tree Swallow | Tachycineta bicolor | Least Concern | Stable | |
Tufted Titmouse | Baeolophus bicolor | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Turkey Vulture | Cathartes aura | Least Concern | Stable | |
Veery | Catharus fuscescens | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Warbling Vireo | Vireo gilvus | Least Concern | Increasing | |
White-breasted Nuthatch | Sitta carolinensis | Least Concern | Increasing | |
White-throated Sparrow | Zonotrichia albicollis | Least Concern | Decreasing | Yes |
Wild Turkey | Meleagri gallopavo | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Wilson's Warbler | Cardellina pusilla | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Winter Wren | Troglodytes hiemalis | Least Concern | Increasing | Yes |
Wood Thrush | Hylocichla mustelina | Least Concern | Decreasing | Yes |
Yellow Warbler | Setophaga petechia | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Yellow-bellied Flycatcher | Empidonax flaviventris | Least Concern | Increasing | Yes |
Yellow-bellied Sapsucker | Sphyrapicus varius | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Yellow-billed Cuckoo | Coccyzus americanus | Least Concern | Decreasing | |
Yellow-rumped Warbler | Setophaga coronata | Least Concern | Unknown | |
Yellow-throated Vireo | Vireo flavifrons | Least Concern | Increasing | |
Yellow-throated Warbler | Setophaga dominica | Least Concern | Increasing |